To know if a foreign man's account is fake, read it as a history, not a count: when it started, whether other people tag him and talk to him, whether he answers, and which country the app says it's based in. Each is a clue, not a verdict, and a thin account can belong to a real, private man.
Contents · 14 sections
Photo counts, friend counts and the profile’s age are a fair start, not an identity check, and they are the easy part to fake. Years of other people talking to him are much harder to fake, though a stolen or bought account keeps its old history, so the question is also who runs it now. You can do all of this for free, without logging into another site or sending him anything. If he asks for money at any point, the checking is over, and you send nothing.
We also read 22 Philippine news reports about Filipinas and men they met online, and found something the usual lists leave out. Of the 9 women in those reports who lost, or nearly lost, money, no report says she looked at his account before he asked for money (a report that doesn’t mention it can’t tell us she never did). The two checks the reports do describe both came after he asked. This page is about how to look, and about looking early.
How to know if it’s a fake account: read it as a history, not a count
Go through his public account as a timeline, from the oldest post you can see to today, and ask the same questions at each step: who else is here, and does he talk back? A real person’s account tends to fill up slowly and untidily, with other people in it. An account made to deceive is often recent, polished and quiet, because a trail of other people takes time to fake. The exception is a stolen or bought account: it keeps someone else’s genuine past, which tells you nothing about who is messaging you now.
| What to look at | A real man’s account tends to show | An account built to fool you tends to show | What it can’t tell you |
|---|---|---|---|
| When it started | Years of history, sometimes with long gaps | Weeks or months old, or old but empty until recently | A new account can follow a divorce, a lost phone or a hacked old one |
| Photos | Ordinary pictures over years, some taken by other people | Polished, model-like pictures, many uploaded on the same day | Good photos can be real, and a man who hates cameras has few |
| Tagged photos | Friends, family or coworkers tag him at events | None, or only pictures he posted himself | Some men switch tagging off |
| Friends and comments | People with their own accounts and lives who talk to him, and he answers | A long friends list where nobody speaks, or comments from accounts as new as his | A big list proves nothing either way, and a stolen account keeps its old friends and comments |
| What he posts | Things that serve no story: a team, a dog, a broken car, a bad haircut | Posts that build a story: a uniform, money, travel, grief, love quotes | A real man can post nothing at all |
| A “based in” label, where the app shows one | A country that fits where he says he lives | A different country, or a story that keeps moving | VPNs can make the label wrong, and many accounts show none |
No single row settles it. What you are weighing is whether the rows point the same way. Philippine police have given the same advice in their own words: the PNP Anti-Cybercrime Group told the Inquirer in 2018 to find out when an account was created, to look at the friends list, and to watch whether anyone talks: “If you find that you and the other person are the only ones conversing, and the friends are always quiet, that would be suspicious.” 1
Years of other people talking to him are harder to fake than photos and friends, but a stolen account keeps them. Check who runs it now, not only whether its past looks real.
Quick poll
Before you got close to a man you met online, did you look through his account?
What 10 Filipinas in the news did with his account
In the stories we read, the only checks of his account that reporters describe came late: of 10 Filipinas, 2 are reported checking his account or his contacts (one woman herself, one a granddaughter), and both did it after money had been asked for. The other reports don’t say whether the women looked, so this is a count of reported checks, not of how often women check. Before you see the rest, take a guess.
Your guess
What came up in these women’s stories?
We read the stories of 10 Filipinas in Philippine news; 9 of them lost, or nearly lost, money to a man they met online. Which of these do you think came up most?